Charlie Sorrel at Wired:
Which one do I prefer? Neither. I have settled on Appleâ€™s own case, which is cheap (ish), slimline and protective. If these two faux-Moleskines could be described as Victorian chaperones, making sure that their charges remain virgin and untouched at the expense of being highly intrusive, the Apple case is more like a Durex Featherlite: it offers protection, but you hardly know itâ€™s there.
The Case from Pen & Quill is significantly more quality than the Dodocase but also more bulk and weight.